We are STILL SHIPPING! Phone orders only, please click here for details.

Active Play

View all
18" Hoppy Balls with Pump - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts - 1
Toysmith
18" Hoppy Ball with Pump
$ 20
View
Aerobie Dogobie Flying Disc - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Aerobie
Aerobie Dogobie Flying Disc
$ 8
View
Aerobie Orbiter Boomerang
Aerobie
Aerobie Orbiter Boomerang
$ 10
View
Air Strike Catapult
Hog Wild
Air Strike Catapult
$ 15
View

Activity Books

View all
Aitoh Unfold the Secrets of Kirigami - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Aitoh
Aitoh Unfold the Secrets of Kirigami
$ 13
View
All Aboard! Trains Activity & Coloring Book
Dover Publications
All Aboard! Trains Activity & Coloring Book
$ 3.99
View
Alphabet Mazes - Coloring/Maze Book - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Dover Publications
Alphabet Mazes - Coloring/Maze Book
$ 3.99
View
Area 51 Passport Notebook (3-3/8” x 4-7/8”)
Unemployed Philosopher's Guild
Area 51 Passport Notebook (3-3/8” x 4-7/8”)
$ 4
View

Art

View all
10 Mini Colored Pencils
Djeco
10 Mini Colored Pencils
$ 5
View
10 Washable Stamp Markers - Animals
Melissa & Doug
10 Washable Stamp Markers - Animals
$ 4
View
Aitoh Unfold the Secrets of Kirigami - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Aitoh
Aitoh Unfold the Secrets of Kirigami
$ 13
View
Batman - Mini Batmobile Wood Paint Set
MasterPieces
Batman - Mini Batmobile Wood Paint Set
$ 10
View

Baby

View all
24 Piece Tegu Magnetic Wooden Block Set, Tints - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts - 1
Tegu
24 Piece Tegu Magnetic Wooden Block Set, Tints
$ 65
View
Alphabet Nesting & Stacking Blocks - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Melissa & Doug
Alphabet Nesting & Stacking Blocks
$ 12
View
Bathtub Stickers Sea Life
Toysmith
Bathtub Stickers Sea Life
$ 13
View
Book Tower Little Animal Books (Melissa & Doug)
Melissa & Doug
Book Tower Little Animal Books (Melissa & Doug)
$ 15
View

Bath Toys

View all
Bathtub Stickers Sea Life
Toysmith
Bathtub Stickers Sea Life
$ 13
View
Classic Yellow Rubber Ducks - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Schylling
Classic Yellow Rubber Ducks
$ 3
View
Cowboy Rubber Ducks - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Schylling
Cowboy Rubber Duck
$ 4
View
Dinosaur Bathtub Stickers
Toysmith
Dinosaur Bathtub Stickers
$ 13
View

Books

View all
Apples to Zeppelin A Rockin' ABC for Cool Kids
Laughing Elephant
Apples to Zeppelin A Rockin' ABC for Cool Kids
$ 10
View
Area 51 Passport Notebook (3-3/8” x 4-7/8”)
Unemployed Philosopher's Guild
Area 51 Passport Notebook (3-3/8” x 4-7/8”)
$ 4
View
Book Tower Little Animal Books (Melissa & Doug)
Melissa & Doug
Book Tower Little Animal Books (Melissa & Doug)
$ 15
View
Book Tower Little Learning Books (Melissa & Doug)
Melissa & Doug
Book Tower Little Learning Books (Melissa & Doug)
$ 15
View

Bundles

View all
Custom Easter Gift Sets
Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Custom Easter Gift Sets
$ 50
View
Djeco Bundle Teens and Grown Ups
Djeco
Djeco Bundle Teens and Grown Ups
$ 100
View
Djeco Bundle Ages 7+
Djeco
Djeco Bundle Ages 7+
$ 100
View
Djeco Bundle Ages 4-6
Djeco
Djeco Bundle Ages 4-6
$ 100
View

Calico Critters

View all
BABY NURSERY SET Calico Critters
Calico Critters
BABY NURSERY SET Calico Critters
$ 20
View
Calico Critters - Adventure Tree House
Calico Critters
Calico Critters - Adventure Tree House
$ 60
View
Calico Critters - Apple & Jake's Ride 'n Play
Calico Critters
Calico Critters - Apple & Jake's Ride 'n Play
$ 22
View
Calico Critters - Baby Friends
Calico Critters
Calico Critters - Baby Friends
$ 13
View

Construction

View all
100 Wood Blocks Set - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Melissa & Doug
100 Wood Blocks Set
$ 20
View
24 Piece Tegu Magnetic Wooden Block Set, Tints - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts - 1
Tegu
24 Piece Tegu Magnetic Wooden Block Set, Tints
$ 65
View
Aqua Maze Twist
MindWare
Aqua Maze Twist
$ 40
View
BRIO - Builder Construction Set
Brio
BRIO - Builder Construction Set
$ 44
View

Dolls & Doll Houses

View all
Bebe Bath Floral Bloom
Corolle
Bebe Bath Floral Bloom
$ 40
View
Bebe Calin Yang
Corolle
Bebe Calin Yang
$ 40
View
Calico Critters - Caramel Dog Family
Calico Critters
Calico Critters - Caramel Dog Family
$ 25
View
Calico Critters - Persian Cat Triplets
Calico Critters
Calico Critters - Persian Cat Triplets
$ 10
View

Dress-Up

View all
Ballerina Jewelry Box - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Schylling
Ballerina Jewelry Box
$ 23
View
Butterfly Dress with Wings and Wand (Medium)
Creative Education
Butterfly Dress with Wings and Wand (Medium)
$ 30
View
Crown Jewels! Dress-Up Tiaras - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Melissa & Doug
Crown Jewels! Dress-Up Tiaras
$ 11
View
Doctor Role Play Costume Set - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts - 1
Melissa & Doug
Doctor Role Play Costume Set
$ 26
View

Education

View all
24 Piece Tegu Magnetic Wooden Block Set, Tints - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts - 1
Tegu
24 Piece Tegu Magnetic Wooden Block Set, Tints
$ 65
View
Brio - Magnetic Stacking Train - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts - 1
Brio
BRIO - Magnetic Stacking Train
$ 26
View
Classic ABC Blocks with Pull Wagon
Uncle Goose
Classic ABC Blocks with Pull Wagon
$ 53
View
Classic Medical Case w/Tools - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Schylling
Doctor's Kit
$ 17
View

Figurines

View all
Brachiosaurus - 14581
Schleich
Brachiosaurus - 14581
$ 24.99
View
Cheetah female - 14746 - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Schleich
Cheetah female - 14746
$ 6.99
View
Classic Wonder Woman Bendable Action Figure - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Toysmith
Classic Wonder Woman Bendable Action Figure
$ 9
View
Coyote - Safari - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Safari Ltd.
Coyote - Safari
$ 5
View

Games

View all
Acorn Soup
Peaceable Kingdom
Acorn Soup
$ 18
View
Aggravation - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Winning Moves
Aggravation
$ 20
View
Alphabet Bingo!
Peaceable Kingdom
Alphabet Bingo!
$ 14
View
Alphabet Go Fish!
Peaceable Kingdom
Alphabet Go Fish!
$ 10
View

Horses

View all
Douglas Teak Chestnut Foal 10" Plush - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Douglas
Douglas Teak Chestnut Foal 10" Plush
$ 14
View
Douglas Zoe Bay Horse 27" - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Douglas
Douglas Zoe Bay Horse 27"
$ 45
View
Fold & Go Stable - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Melissa & Doug
Fold & Go Stable
$ 48
View
Horse Carrier - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts - 1
Melissa & Doug
Horse Carrier
$ 19
View

Kitchen

View all
Butterfly Porcelain Tea Set Basket
Schylling
Butterfly Porcelain Tea Set Basket
$ 30
View
Food Groups - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts - 1
Melissa & Doug
Food Groups
$ 19
View
Forest Friends Tin Tea Set
Schylling
Forest Friends Tin Tea Set
$ 20
View
Green Toys - Tea Set - Blue - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts - 1
Green Toys
Green Toys - Tea Set - Blue
$ 29
View

LEGO

View all
LEGO 10696 Medium Creative Brick Box - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts - 1
LEGO
LEGO 10696 Medium Creative Brick Box
$ 35
View
LEGO City - 60207 Sky Police Drone Chaser
LEGO
LEGO City - 60207 Sky Police Drone Chaser
$ 31
View
Lego 10692 Creative Bricks - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts - 1
LEGO
LEGO Classic 10692 - Creative Bricks
$ 18
View
LEGO Classic 10712 - Bricks and Gears
LEGO
LEGO Classic 10712 - Bricks and Gears
$ 21
View

Music

View all
Band-in-a-Box: Hum! Jangle! Shake! 7 Piece Set
Melissa & Doug
Band-in-a-Box: Hum! Jangle! Shake! 7 Piece Set
$ 25
View
Beginner Band Set - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Melissa & Doug
Beginner Band Set
$ 25
View
Cowboy Guitar - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Schylling
Cowboy Guitar
$ 25
View
Egg Cha Cha - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Toysmith
Egg Cha Cha
$ 3.50
View

Outdoor

View all
18" Hoppy Balls with Pump - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts - 1
Toysmith
18" Hoppy Ball with Pump
$ 20
View
Aerobie Dogobie Flying Disc - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Aerobie
Aerobie Dogobie Flying Disc
$ 8
View
Aerobie Orbiter Boomerang
Aerobie
Aerobie Orbiter Boomerang
$ 10
View
Aqua Maze Twist
MindWare
Aqua Maze Twist
$ 40
View

Plush

View all
Baby Otter Lil' Handful
Douglas
Baby Otter Lil' Handful
$ 11
View
Big Head Twin Spotted Rattlesnake 70"
Wild Republic
Big Head Twin Spotted Rattlesnake 70"
$ 17
View
Burrow Bunny Plush - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Melissa & Doug
Burrow Bunny Plush
$ 15
View
Butter Yellow Lab Mini Plush - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Douglas
Butter Yellow Lab Mini Plush
$ 8
View

Puppets

View all
Beaver Puppet - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Folkmanis
Beaver Puppet
$ 31
View
Small Plush Finger Puppets Asst. - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Schylling
Small Plush Finger Puppets Asst.
$ 4
View

Puzzles

View all
99 Beautiful Places on Earth 1000 pc Puzzle - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Ravensburger
99 Beautiful Places on Earth 1000 pc Puzzle
$ 21
View
At the Airport See Inside Puzzle
Ravensburger
At the Airport See Inside Puzzle
$ 7.50
View
Curse of the Wolves - Escape Puzzle
Ravensburger
Curse of the Wolves - Escape Puzzle
$ 21
View
Dinosaurs Floor Puzzle (48 pc) - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Melissa & Doug
Dinosaurs Floor Puzzle (48 pc)
$ 13
View

Science

View all
A Collection of Owl Pellets
Copernicus
A Collection of Owl Pellets
$ 16
View
Binoculars - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Schylling
Binoculars
$ 10
View
Brew It Yourself Root Beer
Copernicus
Brew It Yourself Root Beer
$ 16
View
Candy Chemistry Experiment Kit
Thames & Kosmos
Candy Chemistry Experiment Kit
$ 35
View

The Ledge

View all
5" Vintage WWII Die Cast Plane
Toysmith
5" Vintage WWII Die Cast Plane
$ 8
View
Air Strike Catapult
Hog Wild
Air Strike Catapult
$ 15
View
Aitoh Unfold the Secrets of Kirigami - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Aitoh
Aitoh Unfold the Secrets of Kirigami
$ 13
View
Apples to Zeppelin A Rockin' ABC for Cool Kids
Laughing Elephant
Apples to Zeppelin A Rockin' ABC for Cool Kids
$ 10
View

Tin Toys and Wind-Ups

View all
Cosmo Robot Tin Wind-Up - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts - 1
Schylling
Cosmo Robot Tin Wind-Up
$ 22
View
Duck on Bike - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts - 1
Schylling
Duck on Bike
$ 20
View
Fuzzy Bunny Wind-Up - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts - 1
Toysmith
Fuzzy Bunny Wind-Up
$ 4.50
View
Fuzzy Chick Wind-Up - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Toysmith
Fuzzy Chick Wind-Up
$ 4.50
View

Vehicles and Trains

View all
5" Vintage WWII Die Cast Plane
Toysmith
5" Vintage WWII Die Cast Plane
$ 8
View
Balloon Powered Boat - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Schylling
Balloon Powered Boat
$ 4.50
View
Balloon Powered Car - Finnegan's Toys & Gifts
Schylling
Balloon Powered Car
$ 3.50
View
Batman - Mini Batmobile Wood Paint Set
MasterPieces
Batman - Mini Batmobile Wood Paint Set
$ 10
View